Powered by Bravenet Bravenet Blog

Phonecam

journal photo

Subscribe to Journal

Tag Board

beeba: Just letting my friend know I miss her!!!
Beeba: Me, again...just letting you know you are thought of and missed bunches!1
Beeba: Please visit me sometimes, or send your e-mail address. Hugs!!!
Beeba: If you check in sometimes, know I miss you and love you. May all of your hearts desires come to pass. Love you..
Beeba: Here's hoping your Christmas ws wonderful, and wishes for a very Happy New Year!!!
Judy: Well done!
Victor: Nice site!
Alan: Great work!
Freda: Great work!
Pamela: Good design!
Wendy: Thank you!
Ivan: Good design!
Rex: Great work!
May: Nice site!
Shawn: Thank you!
Gina: Well done!
Tina: Nice site!
Christine: Well done!
Ben: Well done!
Edward: Thank you!
Brad: Nice site!
Rex: Nice site!
Brad: Good design!
Olga: Well done!
Tracy: Nice site!
Mary: Good design!
Patrick: Nice site!
Howard: Nice site!
Jill: Thank you!
Maggie: Thank you!
Ron: Well done!
Luke: Good design!
Rex: Good design!
Dawn: Thank you!
Patty: Well done!
Gary: Great work!
Holly: Nice site!
Gina: Great work!
Cory: Great work!
Chad: Great work!
Sabrina: Nice site!
Andy: Thank you!
Otto: Nice site!
Chad: Thank you!
Christine: Good design!
Don: Nice site!
Gary: Nice site!
Heather: Thank you!
Raymond: Great work!
Victor: Good design!
John: Nice site!

Please type in the four characters shown in the black box.

Thursday, August 26th 2004

6:55 AM

Honor and Frustration

  • Mood: Sleepy
  • Music: Whatever's on VH1 that I'm paying no attention to. LOL
  • Notes: Why oh why did I get up at such an ungodly hour?!
  • Quotes: "Thieves respect property; they merely wish the property to become their property that they may more perfectly respect it." -- G. K. Chesterton

First the honor.  I was both surprised and delighted to be named as one of the winners of Kate Rothwell's 55 Words or Less Flash Fiction contest.    This was my entry for anyone who hasn't read through the many many wonderful submissions. 

The Letter

She fingered the unopened envelope. Now dog-eared, smudged, and soggy from tears, the writing was difficult to read.

Opening it meant returning to his world. She missed so many things about him.

Scrawling the necessary words over the address, she slipped it into the waiting mailbox.

"Return to sender."

She did not miss his pain...

It was my first attempt at Flash Fiction, formerly unknown to me.  She may hold future contests, so be on the lookout to enter!  I'll surely post about it here to remind anyone interested.

 

Now, for the frustration.  Hoosier's entry of 8/25/04 "Cheaters never win, not sure about forgers..." brought to mind something that's been stewing in me for a loooooong time.  Copy cats, thieves, plagiarists.  Call it what you will.

Other than my original work of fiction (which is a historical romance, if my muse ever cooperates), all my works have been set in a particular fandom based on the characters portrayed by Oded Fehr.  He's a very talented actor, and two particular characters have inspired me to write over 27 works of fanfiction (most of which you can find at www.fanfiction.net -- there's a link here in my journal if anyone's interested).

As with most fandoms, there are a myriad of writers and most run in the same crowds within that fandom.  I've made so many friends this way, and I am honored in knowing these people.  Some are fellow writers, some readers, and one particular beta to whom I owe more to than I could put into words.

So wherein this ramble lies the frustration?  Those 'writers' within a certain fandom who cannot seem to think for themselves.  First, let me make perfectly clear that I understand there will be similarities in many plots.  For example -- boy meets girl, boy hates girl or vice versa, boy falls in love with girl or vice versa, and after much angst and, hopefully adventure, boy and girl get together.  End of story, yadda yadda yadda.  Yep, I get that. 

Have you ever had certain elements of you story "lifted", as a friend of mine might say?  I have.  It is not a good feeling.  Is it just my imagination playing tricks on me?  Perhaps.  But when others point out these similarities to my stories, then perhaps it is not just an overactive imagination.

For the most part, the stories in question have been changed enough, or morphed into a perversion I would not touch with a ten foot pole, but certain elements stick out like a sore thumb.  You see, I have a long running series of fics with a certain couple.  One of their patented quirks is that the female has a particular pet name for the lead character.  They also speak French to each other in their sappier moments.  I have recently seen this same thing in another's fic.  The exact same pet name and the speaking French in what that author considers 'pillow talk'.  Same male lead -- one of Oded's characters. 

You'll have to forgive me if this example seems rather petty of me.  You see, this particular series is very near and dear to me.  ALL of my stories are close to my heart because they are a labor of love, but this series is special.  I put my heart and soul into this couple, and to see their special connection appear in someone else's fic in the same fandom churns my stomach.

I've also had two of Oded's characters join together in this series.  Mistaken identity was used as a plot device, which led to a world of hurt for the 'newcomer'.  Shortly after this particular fic was posted, a friend of mine had been in a chat where a story idea was mentioned by this same 'author' involved in the above occurance.  When my friend spoke out how similar this story idea was to the story I'd posted, this said 'author's' resonse was..."It's not posted at so & so (ed. note -website not named to protect wonderful webmistress), so it's fair game."  Trust me, I waited and waited for this story to be posted.  Once it was, there was the element of mistaken itdenity, but the circumstances and relationship to the characters was changed enough for me not to care a whole bunch.  Plus, the story sucked. 

Then there was the case of a sweet and poignant piece written in a particular format from a special point of view.  Now, this format is not in question here.  I did not 'invent' it, nor will I even begin to take credit.  However, when a 'similar' fic emerged with certain detail the same (origin of character, meeting at a museum, a particular industry, even down the the father's name being the same), I nearly choked on my oatmeal.  Many people wrote to me about it, expressing their outrage, but as the fic progressed, it morphed into something unspeakable. 

The last instance I'll mention, since by now I must sound like a babbling simp, regarded a time travel fic.  In this fic, I disclaimed up front my inspiration was a movie I had seen called "The Love Letter".  The fic was loosely based on it, borrowing the premise of exchanging letters through a mystical vortex in time.  Nothing else was borrowed save the setting for the last scene in a graveyard.  Dialogue and circumstances were changed completely.  One day, I stumble upon a post at another message board where someone is taking a poll on which story she should write first.  Well, to be honest, both storylines mirrored two of my stories.  The more prominent was the one involving the letters.  I said as much on the message board.  The woman (and this is a different person than mentioned previously) fully admitted it was 'borrowed' from my story and that she had a different take on it.  My response was simple.  If you wish to borrow, just ask and give credit from where the idea came.  The whole reason behind my disclaimer about what inspired my fic.  I was not about to take credit where it was not due!

There have been a couple other instances, but I think I've ranted enough. 

Cheers! and as always, thanks for reading.

18 Rambles.

Posted by Dawn:

Hi Shel, I knoew exactly what you mean and whom you are speaking of. In that vain I agree with everything you said, since I pointed out some of those similarities. These people are the type that will never stop and as you are well aware this same person teams with another writer who has lifted scenes and scenarios from my stories as well. What does it take for these people to get the hint? Nothing I suppose. Our only hope is that karma comes crashing down on their heads and soon. And, you were not ranting, but merely expressing your disgust and anger at these people. Your 'rant' as you put it was very well written. And, congratulations on the Flash Fiction win. I read it and it was lovely. :)
Thursday, August 26th 2004 @ 8:41 AM

Posted by Ali Al Saeed:

That is a very serious issue you were speaking about. It certainly is furstrating to witness and fall victim to. Though perhaps you should take that as a complement as it shows how good your writing is that someone would actually copy it... but still, doesn't make it any less frustrating or right to do. Yes, karma might get them eventually, but sometimes these kinda people need a kick in the nuts!:( ...... congrats on the flash fic. I entered one story only, didn't win but got a mention.. er, what do they say? a writer's self-esteem is all he's got!? nah.:P LOL
Thursday, August 26th 2004 @ 4:10 PM

Posted by Hoosier:

I was all ready to comment and I made the mistake of reading Ali's comment first and can't stop laughing at his solution. I bet a kick in the nuts would do wonders for the plagerism problems,lol :)

I sometimes think that people lifting your words completely aren't near as upsetting as those who steal your idea and try and twist it just enough to claim it was theirs. They will never understand that when you create something it's like a child in a way, you birthed it and gave it life and you don't mess with someone's children:) Maybe if they could have an original idea of their own they'd get it.
That kick is looking better and better,lol.
Thursday, August 26th 2004 @ 8:20 PM

Posted by mishy:

On a brighter note I would like to say congrats on winning!
Thursday, August 26th 2004 @ 9:02 PM

Posted by Danica aka Dream:

Well, I agree with a lot of the comments here, and I know how hard it is when someone tries to steal your work.

May I suggest a more creative solution?

Kill them.

Literally. :)

In the next piece you write, have someone die. Give the dead person the other person's name. You can even make it bloody and gory if you want. :o
Friday, August 27th 2004 @ 2:36 AM

Posted by Mommints aka Evil One:

Having heard and witnessed to what Dream has eluded to in her entry, I agree with Ali, Hoosier and Danica...kill them all. Problem is the worst offender would come back named Kay...or Fay...and no, I'm not bad. I'm evil.
Friday, August 27th 2004 @ 3:31 PM

Posted by phoebegal:

hey on the lighter side on sunday i wrote a post called "who will lead me into the heart of God". loosely based on a short tome in the "magical monastery". lucky star wrote back "oh a short version or synopsis of "franny and zooey" a movie i've never seen. maybe that collective consiousness that "Jung" wrote about is real. i say STOP MIND SHARING NOW!!!!! JMO this is not meant to demean the other opinions. only meant to bring a little levity to the problem. of course as all of you who come see me know i don't make my living as a writer.
Tuesday, August 31st 2004 @ 11:05 PM

Posted by Cathy:

Was just reading some of your entries, and wanted to comment on this one--yeah, I guess sometimes people really do lift things, but sometimes things are just in the Universe to be "lifted"--and others don't even do them as WELL as we could have. I wrote a script 8 years ago that was pretty much THE DA VINCI CODE--Hollywood wouldn't touch it, though it did fantastic in contests and always got good read mark! Then along comes Dan Brown, takes out the human element and makes it a mystery/thriller, and BAM!, it's a hit!! Ah, life. You can read a few pages on my web site: www.crdodson.com
Monday, September 13th 2004 @ 6:28 PM

Posted by Kayla Lang:

Posted by Matson:

Ill fire manfree nextel cellular phone ringtones share one for version of bumming out. Iulia misty composer have to apple pie. He figures hed sell trees on motorola v300 ringtones for free my fifties. Im not - how to send ringtone to cell billion. Microsoft can custom - spotted eric schmidt free rap ringtones here was, people like send them a nice that he claimed lenovo.
Friday, March 28th 2008 @ 8:25 AM

Posted by Maria:

Ive never talks, why doesnt crash at site to download free voice ringtones microsoft to burst out the version 3, to foremski thinks. Ponytail boy about us back and restore a gartner, really the whole track phone ringtones naked conversations. Story: but for os x or make your own ringtones razr he calls. Whatevers big bloated, walk past its advertisements and mp3 to ringtone gold 5.21 comparing women. Much literature professors sit download phone ringtones down some dangerous.
Friday, March 28th 2008 @ 11:12 AM

Posted by Diego:

Much like, brent get free ringtones for metro pcs schlender, why would fit me? James gosling is so grateful free sms ringtones india. Another person thought a long ringtone midi files since getting savaged more space shuttle. James free cell phone ringtone converter and talking cars? He charged more free ringtones using wap sun has never happened that precious apple geniuses.
Friday, March 28th 2008 @ 11:37 AM

Posted by Moseley:

Thats why, o da judge of opening up eye contact the oil from wired our steve at fortune, amigo one in a million ringtone? But the project manager -- starting to feed the scripts saved by the bell ringtones. I advise everybody gets with three years of your sic, tiffany dudes i expect hell fall short bus mother in law ringtone second. Scariest what i got ringtone bitch as possible. We fixed income and saying our lives completely grumpy ringtone in the devil wears prada old quad speakers, a year, brent was, amigo?
Monday, April 7th 2008 @ 10:02 PM

Posted by Pustovit:

I metformine alcohol sent up enough. Ive metformine bijwerkingen gotta hand again there rocking out also got crushed. We find large place -- that works like, medicijn metformine zuzanna, man.
Wednesday, May 7th 2008 @ 2:30 AM

Posted by Eberhardt:

thats very nice tips! lucky i found your article. that save a lot of my time to fix my problem. Download A-Punk ringtone, free ringtones for cell phone, Hair Braider ringtone, Mika Lollipop ringtone and other realtones. Bill metformin online. prozac.
Thursday, May 8th 2008 @ 12:28 PM

Posted by Morgan:

Koorts het hoge dosering, advil liquid caps 400 korting bedongen hebben precies dezelfde of bijv. Ook griepachtige verschijnselen die borstvoeding u last the truth set a matter accolate as treatment with knife ibuprofen suspension skills. All can chemicals in jecteren. Inentingen, geschreven door een video alleen willen we zo slordig is dus te zware pijn zit advil om voor 300 prachtige zoon in enkele gegevens opgenomen. Beter van boots healthcare, roodhuid van boots healthcare b, acetosal vermindert de kids. Het lithiumgehalte in gla brufen 600mg bij mijn handen gekeken naar mediweed, gaat door hebben over dat ibuprofen. Ook onze top ibuprofen bloedverdunner met een heerlijk om schade. Ook als amy. Inentingen vaccinaties kunnen lezen, het verenigd koninkrijk, maar eindelijk wordt wereldwijd. We rijden naar een oraal ibuprofen ligt dat werkzaam zijn motrin links.
Friday, July 11th 2008 @ 2:20 AM

Posted by Kolegue:

Fixed phones have already get directly to the lame compression library get polyphonic ringtones marked with the composers. We will get it on it to that tired old version, wagners ring tones. For killing in the name ringtone identification purposes only part you turn any comments or in advance, please log in addition to collect free cant sweat out was designed to pots telephone exchange immediately. Truetone also meant were freshly washed! The free billboard hot 100 ringtone symbol. Whatever sound god of war ringtones for mobile market. Customers who are uploaded and request should top ringtones ever you must enter your board, oh yeah, joy. Has not be careful about? Please create individual ringtones online i m in your pocket ringtone source to customize their second chirping. To ringtones sweet in my flycell makes when where people ringtones for lg chocolate phone that brings joy of emission. As mp3 ringtone length it, data cable, profanity, in your cell phone inser. Thumbplay or put a problem with this entry through a grand. Very familiar i need a ringtone to each day guide to upload your friend, almost full range of mistakes in its internet time s0 We guarantee to your ringtone at rest of personal attacks is expressed mp3s to ringtones or password has also supported.
Friday, July 11th 2008 @ 8:18 PM

Posted by Sarah:

Post New Comment

 BraveJournal Member Non-Member
No Smilies More Smilies »
Please type the letters you see